Skip to content
Accountability

UN Commission Asks ICC to Add Genocide to Netanyahu and Gallant Charges

A new U.N. report finds Israeli forces are extending Gaza's 'extermination and displacement' strategy into the West Bank and says the International Criminal Court should not have left genocide off its 2024 warrants.

By Occupation Watch··2 min read
The International Criminal Court at The Hague in the Netherlands. (justflix/Wikimedia Commons/CC BY-SA 4.0)PHOTO: CONSORTIUM NEWS

Source: Consortium News · published November 1, 2026

The U.N. Independent International Commission of Inquiry on the Occupied Palestinian Territory sent its latest findings to the General Assembly on Oct. 26. The report's conclusion is blunt.

"Israeli authorities and forces continue to commit genocidal acts with the genocidal intent to destroy, in whole or in part, the Palestinians in Gaza."

The Commission, chaired by Srinivasan Muralidhar, also documents what it describes as the migration of that strategy into the West Bank, pointing to the killing and injuring of Palestinian civilians there alongside home demolitions and what the chair calls Israel's "persistent denial of responsibility."

"The intentional killing and injuring of Palestinian civilians and destruction of homes in the West Bank combined with Israel's persistent denial of responsibility form part of a broader strategy to exterminate and displace Palestinians and impose conditions of life that are unliveable," Muralidhar said in a statement accompanying the report. He added that Israel's expanded territorial control in Gaza continues to produce casualties among Palestinians who approach or cross what the military designates the Yellow Line.

A Gap Left Open in 2024

The Commission's recommendation lands against a specific prosecutorial record. In November 2024, the ICC issued arrest warrants for Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and then-Defense Minister Yoav Gallant, the first warrants the court has issued against Israeli officials over the treatment of Palestinians. The charges named war crimes, including starvation as a method of warfare and intentional attacks on civilians, and crimes against humanity including murder and persecution.

Genocide was not among them, despite the International Court of Justice's Jan. 26, 2024 finding that Israel was plausibly committing genocide in Gaza, a ruling that preceded the ICC warrants by ten months.

That omission drew criticism at the time from legal figures who otherwise welcomed the warrants. Raji Sourani, director of the Palestinian Centre for Human Rights, praised then-Prosecutor Karim Khan's applications but pressed the court to also pursue "warrants for the crime of genocide given the staggering evidence of genocidal acts and intent made by top Israeli officials." International law scholar Richard Falk called Khan's request "historic" while naming genocide "the elephant in the room," predicting that its absence would eventually be seen as "the most shocking weakness in the prosecutor's formal statement."

The Commission's new report is an attempt to close that gap, built on its own earlier 2025 findings that it says documented Israel deliberately inflicting death and severe bodily and mental harm on Palestinian children in Gaza.

The Enforcement Problem

A recommendation is not an indictment. The Commission has no prosecutorial power; it can only refer its findings to the General Assembly and, by extension, nudge the ICC prosecutor's office. Whether that office acts depends in part on an institution currently under direct pressure from Washington. The report's release comes as the Trump administration has moved to sanction ICC personnel and structures, part of a broader effort, described in the record, to constrain the court's capacity to pursue cases against Israeli officials.

That leaves the Commission's genocide finding where it has sat since January 2024: documented by multiple U.N. bodies, undisputed by the Commission chair's own language, and still outside the formal charge sheet against the two Israeli leaders currently wanted by the court.

Sources & Documentation

  1. UN Body: Consider Genocide Charges Against Israeli Leaders — Consortium NewsPrimary source; opinion piece by Marjorie Cohn citing UN Commission report and ICC/ICJ record